[Spellyans] Jazz > loan words?
eddie_climo at yahoo.co.uk
Sat Jul 5 16:14:39 IST 2008
On 5 Jul 2008, at 13:34, Michael Everson wrote:
> I favour <jas>, <jasek> myself; and I'd like <pîtsa>.
'Pîtsa' is UCR, of course, and I'd favour either that or
unassimilated italicised 'pizza', according to the writer's personal
taste. And if the writer happens not to use the italicisation (as is
done in NJAW's UCR dictionary), it's hardly a problem.
I think we should be wary of getting too prescriptively persnickety
with these loan words. After all, the overwhelming majority of
Cornish users and learners will be L1 English speakers, and they
should have no actual problem either recognising or pronouncing these
items in Cornish.
In Nicholas's dictionary, there's another loan containing <-zz->:
> E. mezzo-soprano = UCR metsô-soprano
I'd suggest that this is acceptable, as well as <mezzo-soprano> with
or without italicisation. This lexical item is just one of a very
large number of technical terms in music which are used in English
(and elsewhere) with no respelling. And what's true of Music is
likewise true of many other fields as well.
Staying with the current theme, my little Concise Oxford Dictionary
of Music also offers us Mezza, Mezzo, Mezzo Carattere, Mezzo-Staccato
As is well known, Music is stuffed full of Italian, French, German
and English words, and even my *little* dictionary runs to nearly 600
pages --its big brother is a multi-volume encyclopaedia!
Realistically, this vocabulary set is not going to be translated into
Cornish anytime soon, I fancy. It seems we need an ad hoc rule that says
> any foreign-language technical terminology may be used in KS,
> without respelling, provided it is put in italics or quote marks.
Thus, the words listed above all instantly become acceptable in
Cornish when written as follows:
> Mezza, Mezzo, Mezzo Carattere, Mezzo-Staccato, Mezzo-forte.
> 'Mezza', 'Mezzo', 'Mezzo Carattere', 'Mezzo-Staccato', 'Mezzo-forte'.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
More information about the Spellyans